WOMAN OWNED. WOMAN RUN. Free US, Next Day Shipping From MN on Orders $95+

Home / Journal / Materials
Materials

Why Our Jewelry Never Tarnishes (And What That Actually Means)

Leah Mickschl ·Founder, Pretty Simple · ·5 min read

You've bought the jewelry before: cute in the store, green on your skin two weeks later, or tucked in a drawer because it turned dull the first time it touched water. Waterproof, hypoallergenic jewelry isn't a marketing buzzword, it's a completely different way of building a piece so it survives your actual life.


What "Waterproof Jewelry" Actually Means

Most costume jewelry is base metal with a thin plating on top. The moment that plating wears through, from sweat, lotion, chlorine, or just time, the metal underneath reacts, and that's the green tint or tarnish showing up on your skin.

Our Waterproof Collection is built from 18K gold-plated stainless steel with a thicker, more durable plating layer. It's designed to handle showers, pools, sweat, and humidity without breaking down the way traditional costume jewelry does.

Double Love Tennis Bracelet

Why Hypoallergenic Matters

A surprising number of people have a mild sensitivity to nickel, one of the most common metals used in cheap jewelry, without ever realizing that's the reason certain earrings or rings leave their skin irritated. Stainless steel is naturally hypoallergenic, which is why it shows up in body jewelry and medical-grade applications, not just accessories.

If you've ever had to stop wearing a pair of earrings because your ears got itchy or inflamed, that's usually a plating or nickel issue, not a sign you "can't wear jewelry."

Everyday Durable

Waterproof Collection

18K gold-plated stainless steel, hypoallergenic and built to resist tarnish through daily wear, workouts, and humidity

shop collection

How to Actually Care for It

Waterproof doesn't mean maintenance-free forever. A few habits keep any jewelry looking its best:

  • Wipe pieces with a soft cloth after workouts or swimming to remove chlorine or salt residue
  • Avoid direct contact with perfume or lotion right before putting jewelry on
  • Store pieces separately so they don't scratch against harder metals
  • Rinse with fresh water after ocean swims, salt is more corrosive than pool chlorine
Michaela Diamond Chain Necklace

Building a Stack That Lasts

Because the Waterproof Collection holds up to daily wear, it's designed for layering, stacked rings, a mix of earring styles, a couple of thin necklaces at different lengths. Mixed metals used to be a styling risk. With a consistent 18K gold plating across the whole collection, everything is built to match by default.

Explore the full Waterproof Jewelry Collection and the Charm Bar for pieces you can build a stack around.

x