WOMAN OWNED. WOMAN RUN. Free US, Next Day Shipping From MN on Orders $95+

Home / Journal / Style Guide
Style Guide

How to Choose a Wallet That Actually Fits Your Life

Leah Mickschl ·Founder, Pretty Simple · ·5 min read

A wallet is the one accessory you touch a dozen times a day, at checkout, at the gas pump, digging for a rewards card while a line forms behind you. So why do so many of us end up with whatever wallet happened to be cute in the moment, instead of one that actually works for how we live?


Start With What You Actually Carry

Before you fall for a color or pattern, count what goes in your wallet on a normal day: cards, cash, a phone, maybe a key fob or two. If you're a "cards only, tap to pay" person, a slim card holder is all you need. If you're still carrying cash, receipts, and a coupon or two, you need real interior structure, not just a slot or two.

The most common mistake is buying a wallet that photographs beautifully but bulges the second real life gets stuffed into it.

Wonderlust Woven Dual Pouch Wristlet

Card Holder or Full Wallet: How to Decide

Card holders are built for speed. They're thin, they slide into a small bag or back pocket, and they force a little bit of discipline about what you actually carry. Full wallets are built for capacity, cash compartments, a zip pocket for coins, room for a passport or boarding pass when you travel.

If you switch bags often, a slim card holder that can move between them in seconds is worth the trade-off in capacity.

Everyday Favorite

Paris Card Wallet

Pebbled vegan leather, 10 colors, and just enough structure to hold cards and cash without bulk. Our most-repurchased wallet.

Shop Paris, $30

Zip, Snap, or Envelope: Closures Matter More Than You Think

A zip-around wallet keeps everything contained, cards can't slip out even if the wallet gets tossed into a tote bag with keys and lip balm. Snap and envelope closures are faster to open one-handed, better if you're the type constantly juggling a coffee, a toddler, or both.

If you lose things easily, choose zip. If you value speed at checkout, choose snap or envelope.

Lenni Large Zip Woven Wallet

Matching Your Wallet to Your Bag

A wallet doesn't need to match your bag exactly, but the material and hardware tone should feel like they belong to the same wardrobe. A checkered woven wallet pairs naturally with our Woven Vegan Leather Collection, while a smooth pebbled wallet reads more polished alongside structured totes and shoulder bags.

Five Wallets Worth Knowing

The right wallet is the one you stop thinking about, because it just works, every single time you reach for it.

x